Originally released in 1965, this album is a bit of a melting pot of material. Some of it dates back to 1962 including three tracks from The Falcons (for which Pickett sang lead). This was also the first album that Pickett recorded with the famous Stax rhythm section in Memphis. Of course, the big hit here is the title track, but also noteworthy are "Come Home Baby", "Don't Fight It", "I'm Gonna Cry" and "I Found Love".

Track Listing
1. In the Midnight Hour
2. Teardrops Will Fall
3. Take a Little Love
4. For Better or Worse
5. I Found a Love
6. That's a Man's Way
7. I'm Gonna Cry
8. Don't Fight It
9. Take This Love I've Got
10. Come Home Baby
11. I'm Not Tired
12. Let's Kiss and Make Up